Hello!
Okay, it's been an appallingly long time since the last time I blogged. This is my first blog of 2013, and even at New Year I hadn't put anything on here for nearly a month. I've thought of lots of things I've wanted to blog about, I just haven't got around to it. I think it's a self-fulfilling prophecy in a sense - the less frequently I've been blogging, the less likely it is that I'm going to write about something that jumps out at me, because I'm not really sure how to get started talking about it. I am ashamed that I've been letting my blog fall by the wayside so much, hopefully I'll be picking it up again over the next few weeks.
Today I wanted to talk about something that has been occurring more and more to me recently that I feel really strongly about, and that is the relationship between the police and activists/demonstrators such as myself. I'll be honest about the fact that since I started becoming involved in political demonstrations, my respect for them has declined a lot. However, recently I have found that people I have talked to at political demonstrations have a personal vendetta against all police officers. I can understand why they might have this attitude - after all, many of these people have been involved in this side of life for longer than I have - but I have to say, it does annoy me. There are some demonstrators who will see a person in uniform and instantly and instinctively class them as the enemy. I was at a very small demo quite recently, and a few police officers were alerted to it and arrived to make sure that everything was all right. One of the people on the protest - who I won't name to protect the innocent, but they know who they are if they're reading this - spoke to the officers in an extremely rude and unpleasant manner, and I did actually speak to him afterwards to tell him that I thought that he was being quite unfair. I don't actually see all the police as being enemies. Some are, absolutely, and if on this occasion the officers had been trying to move us or cause trouble to our cause, I would have completely stood by my colleague's actions. However, I think that one's manner should always start off polite, and after that it depends on what you get from the other party. Being unpleasant to someone because of what they represent is very judgemental, and actually sounds to me like the very attitude that we campaign against in the first place. I don't appreciate the police and other authority figures such as politicians writing activists and anarchists off as troublemakers; therefore I don't do the same thing myself. Plus, you never know in advance what the police at a demonstration will be like; sometimes they are aggressive and intimidating, while at other times they just try to keep the peace. Occasionally they are openly supportive of the cause - it doesn't happen as often as I'd like it to, but you come across it from time to time.
This weekend I took part in a workshop about direct action, and this debate came up in the discussion. I said that while I appreciate that it is sometimes not feasible - and in fact, it probably isn't feasible the majority of the time - I think that it is good to be completely open with the police at demonstrations. Someone else - who is considerably more experienced than I am - said that they completely disagreed with me, and thought that it is best to keep one's plans for a demonstration as private from the police as possible. From a realistic perspective, I suppose I agree with that; the way it works at the moment is that a group of people form a demo, an inordinately large number of officers arrive and then either attempt to disperse the group or let them carry on with it - but the majority of the time, it is difficult to actually make any kind of difference without behaving in a way that is likely to get someone arrested. Because of this, a lot of the time a successful protest or demonstration relies on having the element of surprise against the police, and therefore, it is not a good idea to be open with them about your plans. You might ask then, why I think protestors should be open with the police at demos. Well, people who know me know that I am an idealist, and as an idealist I think that there are better ways for demos and protests to be run, on the side of both the demonstrators and the police. I would in no way condone demonstrators to be 100% open with the police the way that things stand at the moment; that is not what I was saying at all. What I think is that there should be a system whereby the police and demonstrators can be open with one another.
For this to happen, there are really two things that need to be worked out. Firstly, powers of arrest need to be limited to a much lesser extent than they are now. At the moment, people can be arrested at protests for things that just do not add up - if the police wish to arrest someone, whatever that person is doing. they will be able to find a clause in an Act somewhere which allows them to arrest that person for something. As a political activist and also a former law student, I have been amazed over the past few years by how many powers of arrest there are, particularly in situations high in emotion such as political demonstrations. These powers need to be limited if the protest movement has any chance of succeeding in its vocations. The second thing is an increase in knowledge of everything on both sides. Both demonstrators and the police need to be fully aware of EXACTLY what is legal and what is not, so that no one will be wrongly arrested and no one will do anything that they do not know to be illegal (although I think that the powers of arrest ought to be basic enough for it to be obvious to everyone what they can be arrested for, but still it's a safeguard.) Also, the police should be aware of what has been arranged in advance, and stick to that. You can't always trust the police to be fair - if, for example, you have planned for a certain number of people to join the demonstration at a particular time, and the officers on duty claim to have not been made aware of this, then that arrangement is not honoured, and I think that is not on. I think that there should be a system where the police and protesters can work together, fairly and honestly. If that were the case, there would be fewer arrests at demonstrations, the police would not be victimised by demonstrators and anarchists in the way that they are, and the world of political activism would not be so dark. Because it is dark, it pains me to say. I am aware that there are certain things that I am involved with that it is dangerous to talk about in certain places and with certain people. I find this rather frustrating, because I am a passionate supporter of freedom of information, and if I could, I'd tell everyone what was going on. The only reason I can't do that is because I'm worried about what some people might do with that information.
Well, that's it then! Apologies once again for the really long gap between blogs. I hope to get back into blogging regularly. I do enjoy it immensely once I get down to it.
Take care, guys!
No comments:
Post a Comment